The World's Most Underrated Islands: A Traveler's Guide
Island vacations often bring to mind popular destinations like the Maldives, Bora Bora, or the Greek Isles. Some of the most enchanting and unique experiences can be found in lesser-known islands that remain untouched by mass tourism. These hidden gems offer unparalleled natural beauty, authentic cultural encounters, and a sense of discovery that's increasingly rare. Whether you're seeking solitude, adventure, or an off-the-beaten-path escape, these underrated islands promise unforgettable moments for travelers willing to explore beyond the usual hotspots.
1. Flatey Island, Iceland
Flatey Island is a small but remarkable gem located in Breiðafjörður Bay, Iceland. With its vibrant summer months, the island is known for its rich birdlife and rustic charm. What makes Flatey special is its simplicity, time seems to stand still here as you wander through colorful cottages and encounter friendly locals. The island's history dates back to early Norse settlements, adding an intriguing historical layer to your visit.
One of the most captivating aspects of Flatey is its minimalism. With only a handful of permanent residents and no cars allowed, it’s an ideal location for those looking to unplug. Visitors can enjoy fresh seafood at the island’s only restaurant or take leisurely walks along the shoreline. The Flatey Church, adorned with beautiful frescoes by artist Baltasar Samper, is another must-see.
Reaching Flatey is relatively simple via ferry from Stykkishólmur or Brjánslækur during the summer months. Its remoteness and unspoiled landscapes make it an exceptional choice for travelers craving peace and authenticity.
2. Caye Caulker, Belize
Caye Caulker might not get as much attention as its larger neighbor Ambergris Caye, but this tiny island off Belize’s coast offers a laid-back vibe that’s hard to resist. The motto here is “Go Slow,” which perfectly encapsulates the island’s ethos. With sandy streets where golf carts outnumber cars and hammocks scattered along the shoreline, it’s a destination designed for relaxation.
The island is a paradise for snorkeling and diving enthusiasts. It’s located near the Belize Barrier Reef Reserve System, a UNESCO World Heritage site teeming with marine life. Shark Ray Alley and Hol Chan Marine Reserve are popular spots where you can swim alongside nurse sharks, stingrays, and vibrant coral reefs.
- Best time to visit: December to May (dry season)
- Activities: Snorkeling, diving, kayaking
- Transportation: Accessible via water taxi from Belize City
Caye Caulker offers affordable accommodations ranging from beachside bungalows to eco-lodges. Its unpretentious charm makes it a perfect choice for budget-conscious travelers seeking a tropical getaway.
3. Isle of Mull, Scotland
The Isle of Mull in Scotland provides a stunning mix of rugged coastlines, rolling hills, and quaint villages. Known for its wildlife (including otters, seals, and golden eagles) the island also features historical landmarks such as Duart Castle. Tobermory, Mull’s main town, is famous for its colorful waterfront buildings and serves as an excellent base for exploring the region.
Mull caters to nature lovers with opportunities for hiking along scenic trails or exploring uninhabited nearby islands like Staffa. Staffa is home to Fingal's Cave, known for its unique basalt columns that inspired composer Felix Mendelssohn.
The local culinary scene shouldn’t be overlooked either; seafood dishes like scallops and langoustines are highlights at restaurants across the island. Ferries to Mull operate frequently from Oban on mainland Scotland.
4. São Jorge Island, Azores
Part of Portugal’s Azores archipelago in the North Atlantic Ocean, São Jorge Island stands out for its dramatic cliffs and lush green pastures. It’s particularly popular among hikers thanks to its network of trails that traverse volcanic landscapes and connect charming villages.
The island’s unique geography has given rise to “fajãs,” flat coastal areas formed by lava flows or landslides over centuries. Fajã da Caldeira de Santo Cristo is one such area renowned for its natural beauty and excellent surf conditions.
Cultural traditions remain strong on São Jorge, don’t miss tasting locally produced São Jorge cheese, which has been made using age-old techniques since the 15th century. Flights from Lisbon or ferries between islands provide access to this hidden treasure.
5. Koh Rong Samloem, Cambodia
If pristine beaches surrounded by turquoise waters are what you’re after, Koh Rong Samloem in Cambodia might be your dream destination. Unlike its more commercialized neighbor Koh Rong, this smaller island maintains a quieter ambiance ideal for relaxation.
Saracen Bay serves as the main tourist hub with resorts catering to varying budgets while retaining a focus on sustainability. Adventure-seekers can kayak through mangroves or explore underwater ecosystems via snorkeling trips.
Koh Rong Samloem also offers bioluminescent plankton tours, a magical experience where glowing microorganisms light up the waters during nighttime excursions.
6. Flores Island, Indonesia
Flores Island in Indonesia is often overshadowed by Bali but holds equally enchanting wonders waiting to be discovered. It’s best known as the gateway to Komodo National Park where visitors can encounter Komodo dragons in their natural habitat.
Beyond this wildlife spectacle lies Kelimutu National Park featuring three crater lakes that change colors due to varying mineral compositions, a phenomenon that attracts geologists worldwide.
The local culture on Flores offers another layer worth exploring; traditional villages like Wae Rebo preserve indigenous customs amidst mountainous settings steeped in spirituality.
The islands discussed here reveal that some of the most extraordinary travel experiences lie beyond mainstream destinations. Each one offers something unique (whether it's Iceland's tranquil Flatey Island or Cambodia's serene Koh Rong Samloem) and showcases how diverse our planet truly is when it comes to natural beauty and cultural heritage.